ACLU of Mass. and Liberal Mayors File with
State to Get Details Made Public on NSA Wiretaps
The ACLU
of Massachusetts filed a complaint with the states Department of Telecommunications
and Energy on behalf of the liberal mayors of four cities, Newton,
Somerville, Chicopee and Northampton, alleging that Verizon and AT&T
enabled “illegal” government spying by turning over private
details about phone records to the National Security Agency without
proper warrants.
Yesterday, they renewed
a call to have public meetings detailing exactly what the phone companies
revealed. Both Verizon and AT&T have urged the state agency to
dismiss the complaint.
The ACLU filing comes on
the heels of a federal court ruling last Thursday in Michigan that
the Bush Administration’s program to monitor the phone calls
and e-mails of Americans without warrants is unconstitutional and
must be stopped.
The wiretap issue was first
brought to public knowledge by the New York Times last December when
it published a 3,600 word article critiquing the NSA policy. The White
House had tried to dissuade the newspaper from running the story on
the grounds that “it could jeopardize continuing investigations
and alert would-be terrorists that they might be under scrutiny."
It is thought by many that the New York Times alerting potential terrorists
that the government can monitor their calls is akin to letting Nazi
Germany know that we cracked their “Enigma” code during
WWII.
Verizon has publicly denied
not only providing any information on call records, but also even
being petitioned by the NSA to do so. AT&T acknowledges that they
have cooperated with the NSA, but that the nature of the information
required by the NSA was not specific calls by individuals, but just
access to network monitors which can electronically search for certain
calling patterns or anomalies associated with possible terrorist activity.
Massachusetts law requires
the state agency to hold a public hearing if a written complaint is
filed on behalf of any Massachusetts mayor.
In Vermont, Governor Jim
Douglas is supporting a similar investigation of the telecommunication
companies, despite a threat from the federal government to sue the
state. "We don’t want this kind of intrusion into the privacy
of Vermonters by anyone, by government, or by companies" said
Douglas.
In Connecticut, the Department
of Public Utility Control denied Verizon's motion to dismiss a complaint
from the ACLU of Connecticut, and has scheduled a hearing for September
6.